Early days

Posted: December 1st, 2009 | Author: Dan Misener | Filed under: Uncategorized | Tags: , , , , , | No Comments »

What are the major consequences of internet on society and culture? Perhaps it’s too early to tell.

Clay Shirky, on last week’s episode of Spark:

If you had gone to Germany in the mid-1470s and said, let’s see what this printing press is doing, right, you would miss novels, you would miss newspapers, you would miss the rise of scientific publication, you would miss Martin Luther’s “95 Theses,” you would miss the Venetian publishing industry. So many of the changes brought by the kind of abundance created by the printing press were in the second 50 years of its existence, if not the second century of its existence, that I think that over-extrapolating from current trends would leave us in the same position as if we tried to do the printing press in 1473.

And Bob Stein, on last week’s episode of On The Media:

Here’s a wonderful sort of factoid which may be helpful: The Western version of the printing press is invented in 1454. It takes 50 years for page numbers to emerge. It took humans that long to figure out that it might be useful to put numbers onto the pages.

Or, as management-types like to say, “It’s early days.”


Correlation ≠ Causation

Posted: November 23rd, 2009 | Author: Dan Misener | Filed under: Uncategorized, internet | Tags: | No Comments »

Lee Rainnie, director of the Pew Internet and American Life project, from this week’s On the Media, speaking about social isolation and internet use:

For centuries, when new technologies come on the scene there’s almost an instinctive human reaction, particularly among those who are challenged by the new technology, to blame the technology for any social ill that happens to arise at the same time. Something has gone on with our social networks in the past 20 years. Our data matched the data that the previous researchers had collected showing the networks are shrinking.

And so, now we’re inviting other social scientists and researchers like ourselves to go out and find the real culprit and not just think that the Internet lies behind it just because the Internet was being adopted at the same time this harmful social trend was emerging.

Reminds me a bit of Russell Davies’s The Internet Isn’t Killing Anything.